recommended
sustenance

Login
cheers

Featured in Alltop

« Carnival of Homeschooling | Main | The Youngest Learners »
Monday
27Oct2008

An Argument for Inclusion

Some years ago my studio teacher showed me an online forum of art teachers where one person was expressing her annoyance at having to teach Kindergarten students, which she felt was “a waste of my time”. Other teachers chimed in with sympathy and understanding.

Now that doesn’t represent all art teachers, of course; my friend was indignant and said she wished these men and women could visit her studio and see the work produced by three- and four-year-olds. They were expressive, creative, and meaningful — actually, much more so than the typical cookie-cutter art produced by older children at many schools.

Yesterday I mused about the blog posts I’ve read recently about “distracting” little children when their older siblings are busy learning. Many adults, both at home and in school, seem to think that investing time helping the youngest learners is time better spent elsewhere.

Another post for another day, but I get tired of hearing “children’s work is play” used as an excuse to put small children in the corner with a box of blocks. Children’s work is play, but that doesn’t make it any less meaningful or less worthy of attention and support. They learn through play; they express what they know through play. That isn’t to say that it isn’t also their work.

Why should small children be wooed away from older children who are hard at work?

The child who is digging in the dirt with a stick at the edge of the group will swiftly (as we mothers know) turn into a child who has the ability to participate fully. You can take advantage of exposing her to the type of work you hope she will do, or you can try to distract her away from it to make more room for the older children.

In doing so, you do a disservice to both groups. The younger children are losing the chance to learn in the easiest, most pleasant way — at the feet of their loved ones. The older ones are losing their chance to display their mastery to an adoring audience. In a mixed group of children, both groups benefit.

If you are teaching a traditional curriculum, dedicating a portion of your schedule to project-based learning will allow your children to not only acquire basic skills but learn to apply them, acquiring valuable habits of mind along the way. Letting your youngest children marinate in this atmosphere of engaged, excited learning is the best way to effortlessly raise relentless learners.

If you are unschooling, introducing preschool-age children to project work means that by age five or six you will have what I call a project-oriented child — an avid learner who reaches confidently for resources (including adults) to learn about what excites his interest.

Reader Comments (23)

I have this child, the 5 year old that is project-oriented, but I am struggling with a 4 year-old that is not interested and a 22 month old who is very interested and busy and in the middle of things. I dream of us all working together and around eachother, but in reality it's hard right now. I'm really struggling with it!
I'm really interested in your thoughts on the little ones.
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered Commenternancy
Here, here!!!! I agree -- these Littles are of equal importance!
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterSally
nancy, we should probably take this to the forum -- *because you know how wordy we get* ;^) -- but .. when you say your 4-year-old is not interested .. do you mean not interested in the same thing as your 5yo? or not interested in anything at all?

re: your 22mo, i hear you! it would be great if we could live in layers so that the 5yo could have legos and glitter that never reached the 22mo layer... or maybe alternate dimensions...

you have your hands full, for sure. i don't mean to downplay how hard it is, only highlight that young children can also get hooked on projects. my sons are three years apart and i well remember when the older was 4 and the younger was 1 and right in the center of the action. :^)

sally, yay! let's do the wave again. ;^)
October 27, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
I sense that this is true for my kids, but I am not sure how to work with them to encourage this type of learning. Your blog is really making me think, and I look forward to reading more. Thank you!
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterSara
sara, thank you! i look forward to talking more about it, in the blog and in the forum. i don't believe there is some ideal, perfect way to homeschool, unschool, or educate children. but i do believe that working thoughtfully and reflecting on our practices makes a huge difference. thank you again!
October 27, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
I am loving this topic... we all school on our own stuff alongside each other everyday, I love it - I know where everyone is and there is always someone to help anybody who gets stuck - needs a crayon, needs help sticking whatever. I am always surprised when people ask what I do with my toddlers during school... they are doing "school" with us - of course! I certainly don't want them out of the way and out of sight... and yes it can get distracting but that is something we all have to learn to work with.
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterse7en
me, too, se7en .. love talking about the littlest members. somehow taking them into consideration seems to set the right tone for all of us.
October 27, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
This is my first visit to your blog. Thanks for leaving a comment on mine so I could find you.
My kids are 2 and 5 years. They love, love art. We have the art supplies out with in reach at all times. They have their own little space at each end of the table and love to hold things up to show the other. This also makes it easy for me to keep their supplies seperate if my older daughter is working with things that are not appropriate for her little brother. We have two containers full of all the things they use most often so they can each have some at "their" end. They are great at asking for different colors, etc. that the other has. It is just such a wonderful part of our life. I can't imagine my house without the amazing art of both of my children. My 2 yr old points out his art around the house. "I draw that", I paint that." He is so proud to see his work up along side grandma's paintings and mom's photos. Include the little ones? No question about it! Without a doubt worth any extra effort!
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterDawn
amen, sis! not to mention that i learn a thousand things from my three and one year old and their cohorts every single day.
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered Commentercate
I also wrangle with the levels of play and learning in a 5 year old world and a 2 year old world... so very different. I encourage my older daughter to talk things out in front of, and teach her little sister things. I also remind her that we all have something to learn and to teach. I love to see them working together. Rare but amazing moments!
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterjeannine
oh this is good. (is that how i start every comment on here)...and have I got some photos for you of this point exactly. I'm posting them now...(which will take me forever with my creeping DSL connection.) I'll let you know when they're up...
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered Commentermolly
Very well said -- I think fostering creativity early on is important; they develop so quickly and pick up on things so fast! (Thanks for visiting my blog!)
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterKaren
dawn, i love watching my boys work at opposite ends of the table, too, showing each other their work. :^) they can be very argumentative in general (lol) but when they are drawing and making art they tend to be extremely polite and complimentary!

cate, absolutely. :^)

jeannine, i love the way you phrased that - each girl (and each age) having their own world. so true. and then they come together and make another, shared world. :^)

molly, the pictures of elizabeth getting into the act are so great. :^)

karen, thank you for visiting me! and i agree - the earlier, the better. :^)
October 27, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
Hi there
Thanks for your comment on my blog, how did you find me? I'm glad you did as I plan to homeschool my little ones and your website looks very interesting, I'm sure I will be visiting here often.
October 27, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterHanna
hanna, thank you! and i hope i see you in the comments or the forum. :^) i was blog hopping and followed you from a comment you left on .. ooh, can't remember which blog now, lol. one of my favorite evening pastimes - at least, when the boys are upstairs watching a movie together. ;^)
October 27, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
I mostly agree with this post, but I was suprised to see you dislike the term 'child's work is their play.' I have always thought of that statement not to mean that you put your child in a corner with some blocks, but to remind parents that they don't have to fill up their child's every moment with activity (sports, classes, extra learning), because kids learn a lot just while playing.
October 28, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMelissa Markham
And the little ones are so much fun!
October 28, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterMeryl
Melissa, I agree with you completely!

What I said: “I get tired of hearing “children’s work is play” used as an excuse to put small children in the corner with a box of blocks. Children’s work is play, but that doesn’t make it any less meaningful or less worthy of attention and support. They learn through play; they express what they know through play. That isn’t to say that it isn’t also their work.”

I don’t have any quibble with the phrase, just the way some people seem to apply it — as an excuse for distracting small children with playthings and giving attention to the intellectual pursuits of older children. Rather, I see play as the way that small children learn and articulate their questions and what they know — so, rich play experiences that are really meaningful to the child are my goal.

Hope I did a better job expressing myself this time. :^)
October 28, 2008 | Registered CommenterLori
Wow...what a great thought provoking post! I too have older and younger children and I am homeschooling them...being a former pre-school teacher and director I didn't even think that the young ones would be a bother...but I guess I can see how that can happen if something is not found for them to do prior to starting the older children's school work. I do believe that a young child's mind is very important!

Thanks again for your thought provoking post :o)

~simply stork~
October 28, 2008 | Unregistered Commentersimply

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.